All cases

Read this case in Russian

A plumber filled his schedule and appeared in ChatGPT and Gemini recommendations. We failed to explain the cost of our work.

This case is told from the founder’s memory; figures are as he recalls them, not from a report. Details changed.

Independent plumber case study cover

Who this case is for

An independent plumber and boiler installer.

  • Before: The tradesperson depended on one shop and lacked steady direct enquiries.
  • What we did: We built a simple website, set up Maps and placed twelve local articles.
  • Mistake examined: We did not explain the cost of starting without an advance, and a personal number reached people expecting free help.

All cases · Plumbing company · Pest control service

A skilled independent plumber and boiler installer depended on one offline shop for much of his work. He could do the jobs, but did not have a steady, direct route through which unfamiliar customers could find him.

We built a simple website, set up a Google Maps profile and prepared twelve local articles. Later, we observed repeated recommendations for the tradesperson in ChatGPT and Gemini, and his schedule filled.

Then the founder’s personal phone number started reaching the client’s acquaintances. They expected the same help for free.

We had begun without an advance payment and had failed to explain the value and boundaries of that arrangement clearly enough.

What brought the client to us

The plumber’s relationship with the shop brought work, but it also left him dependent on someone else’s customer contact point.

People introduced through that relationship could hire him. People outside it had little opportunity to discover him independently.

The founder recalls competitors with websites charging as much as three times the plumber’s price. This was a comparison remembered from that situation, not a formal market survey or a claim about every competitor.

What interested us was the gap between the tradesperson’s ability to do the work and his visibility to prospective customers.

We offered to test a different way of presenting the service. The project began without an upfront fee, with payment linked to the result.

That distinction would become the source of our mistake.

What the review revealed

The plumber’s experience did not automatically make him easy to find.

A new customer needed a straightforward account of his services and a way to contact him. We did not need a large website to start providing that information.

The work also had to suit an independent tradesperson. He had no marketing department to run a complicated publishing operation.

We chose a small set of practical elements: a clear website, a Maps profile and local articles.

At the same time, we did not check that he understood the commercial arrangement in the same way we did. For us, it was work without an advance payment. To him, it appeared to be free help.

What we did

Built a simple website

The domain combined the profession and the city name. Neither the domain nor the city is disclosed in this case.

The wording made the subject and area clear. We do not claim that the domain itself secured a search position or an AI recommendation.

The website formed part of a wider set of work. Its role was to introduce the plumber’s services and provide a route to contact him.

Set up the Google Maps profile

The plumber’s home address was used when the profile was set up.

That is a historical detail, not advice to expose a home address publicly. An address used to establish a business and an address shown to customers are different matters.

For a business that visits customers and does not receive them at its address, Google says the address should be hidden and the service area used. Current setup must reflect how the business actually operates. Google’s business representation guidelines.

We do not claim that this plumber received customers at home, or disclose personal address information.

Prepared and placed twelve local articles

We wrote and placed twelve articles connected with the plumber’s services and local market.

This made information about his work available beyond his own website. The articles formed part of the effort to help people discover and understand the service.

The source account does not provide a complete list of article titles, publications or search prompts. We do not reconstruct one.

Began on a payment-by-results basis

We accepted a start without an advance payment. That did not mean the work had no cost.

We should have explained the value, scope and payment conditions more clearly before beginning. Instead, we concentrated on delivering the work and assumed the arrangement had been understood.

What happened

The founder recalls the plumber’s schedule filling. The tradesperson gained direct enquiries and became less dependent on the one shop.

We also observed repeated recommendations in ChatGPT and Gemini.

That is a statement about what we saw. We cannot identify the internal reason for each recommendation or promise that a service will continue to appear in future answers.

Nor can this account separate the effect of the descriptive domain from the profile and articles. They were parts of the same project.

There is no recalled revenue total, precise order count or completion period in the source account. A full schedule is the result described by the founder. It does not need an invented percentage attached to it.

For the client, the useful change was being found directly. For the agency, success exposed an avoidable problem with expectations.

Our mistakes and what we changed

We failed to explain what “no advance payment” meant

At the time, the agency valued its work at $150 an hour. The client did not know that.

He remembered the absence of an initial payment. After the project succeeded, he shared the founder’s personal phone number with acquaintances who expected the same free service.

It would be convenient to describe this simply as a difficult client. Our own communication had helped create the expectation.

We had not made the price, scope and limits of the special arrangement clear enough for the client to explain them accurately to someone else.

The one condition he could easily repeat was that we had started without being paid in advance.

We changed our approach. Even in a test project, we explain the value of the work and the agreed scope at the beginning. If payment depends on a result, the trigger and boundaries need to be understood by both sides.

The $150 figure belongs to this historical account. It is not a current Madloba Consult tariff.

We allowed a personal number to become the route for new business

The founder’s private contact details circulated together with the expectation of free help.

We had not separated personal access from a normal business enquiry process. By the time we addressed it, other people already had the number.

The practical change was to separate work and personal phones. New enquiries should arrive through a channel where the task, conditions and next step can be discussed clearly.

A special arrangement with one client also needs to remain specific to that client. A recommendation introduces a potential customer; it does not determine the price or terms of their future project.

What another business owner can take from this

  1. Understand your dependence on a single intermediary. A shop or partner can be valuable while you also develop a direct contact route.
  2. Explain your service in ordinary language. A new customer needs to know what you do and how to reach you.
  3. Connect visibility with actual enquiries. Appearing in an AI answer does not, on its own, tell you how many jobs were won.
  4. Explain the price even when the initial terms are unusual. No advance payment can easily be misunderstood as no payment at all.
  5. Separate personal and business contact details. It gives new enquiries a clearer place to begin.

Questions and answers

Can an independent tradesperson appear in ChatGPT and Gemini recommendations?

We observed that happening in this project. It is not a promise to every tradesperson, and answers can change.

Is a profession-and-city domain necessary?

That was the domain format used here. We also worked on the profile and twelve articles. The separate contribution of the domain was not measured, so we cannot call it a necessary condition.

Should a plumber publish a home address?

The historical use of an address does not establish that it should be public. The profile must reflect whether customers are received there or the business travels to them, in line with Google’s rules.

Was this a free project?

It began without an advance payment, with payment tied to the result. Our error was failing to make that distinction clear enough.

How many jobs did the plumber receive?

The founder remembers a full schedule. The account does not include an exact number of jobs.

Get a consultation

All cases