All cases

Read this case in Russian

A plumbing company spent €5,000 on a website. Google Maps became its main source of enquiries.

This case is told from the founder’s memory; figures are as he recalls them, not from a report. Details changed.

Plumbing company case study cover

Who this case is for

A plumbing company serving household customers.

  • Before: A €5,000 website was bringing no enquiries.
  • What we did: We separated call sources, reworked Maps and directory profiles, and built service pages.
  • Mistake examined: Verbal agreements led to a dispute about the scope of work.

All cases · Independent plumber · Pest control service

The phone was ringing. The website developers took that as evidence that their work was paying off. The owner of the plumbing company was less convinced: many callers seemed to come through old business cards and personal recommendations.

The company had spent roughly €5,000 and six months on a corporate website. It looked elaborate, with animation and carefully designed visual effects. But nobody could clearly connect those incoming calls to the new site.

We put a separate phone number on it. During the period we observed, that number brought no enquiries. That finding changed where the owner wanted to invest. It also started a project that exposed an uncomfortable weakness in our own working arrangements.

What brought the client to us

The company provided a full range of plumbing services. It wanted to reach beyond its established network, including people from abroad living in the region. A new website had seemed a reasonable way to do that.

A substantial amount of work went into its appearance. Once it launched, however, the owner could not answer a basic question: which customers had actually found the business through it?

The company had no access to Google Analytics or Search Console. Nor was there a separate record of enquiries from the website. Calls to the existing business number could have come from almost anywhere.

The developers attributed those calls to the site. The owner suspected that the business was still living on its older relationships. Both explanations relied on the same ringing phone.

Before proposing more promotion, we needed to distinguish those sources.

What the review revealed

A dedicated website number gave us a practical starting point. It separated calls made using the site’s contact details from calls to the company’s established number.

The old site generated no enquiries in the period described here. That is the result the founder remembers. It is not a claim that the site had no visitors, or that every interaction with it could be reconstructed.

We also examined the experience of someone who needed a plumber. Pages loaded slowly. Prices, guarantees and response-time information were difficult to find. There were problems with the pages appearing in search.

The visual treatment did little to answer the questions that came before a booking. Could this company handle the job? What would the service involve? How could the customer reach someone quickly?

Further investment in the same design would not, by itself, resolve those problems. We recommended a different allocation of effort.

What we did

Gave each source its own contact number

After putting a separate number on the old website, we used distinct numbers for Google Maps, directories and the new service pages.

This gave the owner a clearer view of which contact route people were using. It also stopped us from crediting every incoming call to whichever marketing activity happened to be under discussion.

That distinction mattered throughout the project. An established business already has sources of enquiries. New work should not automatically receive credit for them.

Reworked the Google Maps profile

We updated the business profile, including its categories and opening hours, and organised a process for requesting genuine customer reviews.

The purpose was straightforward: make the company’s services and contact details easier to understand when someone was looking for a local plumber.

The founder recalls the cost of this part of the work as approximately $500. This is a historical project figure, not Madloba Consult’s current price.

Added detailed regional directory listings

We prepared expanded company profiles in local directories, including Madloba. These provided additional places for people to find the business and contact it.

Directory enquiries had their own tracking numbers. Later, they accounted for a substantial share of the enquiries the founder remembers.

Published regional articles

We prepared expert articles about the company’s services and placed them on regional resources. The recalled cost was about $100 per article.

One aim was to make useful information about the business available beyond its own website, including for search and AI-assisted discovery.

We did not separately identify enquiries from ChatGPT or other assistants in the final breakdown. It would therefore be misleading to assign part of the result to those services. The remembered figures concern Maps, directories and direct enquiries.

Built simple pages for specific services

We created fast, focused pages for individual services, such as pipe repairs and heating installation. Prices and a clear way to call were easy to find.

A person with a specific problem could go directly to the relevant service information. The structure followed the job the customer needed done.

These pages are an important part of the story. We continued to use a website, but changed what it was expected to do and how it presented the service.

Redirected the budget

The founder remembers the new programme costing about $1,000 overall, compared with approximately €5,000 spent on the earlier website.

Those figures involve different currencies and different scopes of work. They should not be turned into an exact cost-saving multiple. For this owner, the useful comparison was between spending without a clear source of enquiries and work that produced identifiable contact routes.

What happened

After roughly two months, the company was receiving enquiries for the services it wanted to sell.

The founder recalls the distribution as follows:

Source Approximate share of enquiries
Google Maps profile 60%
Regional directories 30%
Direct and other incidental enquiries 10%
Previous corporate website 0%

These are remembered proportions, not a reproduced analytics report. They describe the pattern that stood out: Maps supplied most enquiries, directories supplied a meaningful share, and the old website supplied none in the observed period.

The client stopped investing in the upkeep of the previous website and redirected the budget towards local visibility and content.

We are describing enquiries, not completed jobs or revenue. The source account does not provide figures that would justify turning this breakdown into a sales calculation.

Nor does this distribution predict what another plumbing company will achieve. The useful result was that this owner could finally make decisions with a clearer understanding of where calls were coming from.

Our mistake and what we changed

We left too much of the agreement in conversation

The promotional work made progress. Our handling of agreements was less disciplined.

Some tasks and conditions were discussed verbally or in voice messages. Later, the client remembered parts of the agreement differently. We found ourselves arguing about what had been promised before we could discuss whether it had been delivered.

The owner’s recollection includes a familiar objection: that was not what we had agreed.

We had not created one written account of the scope that both sides could refer to. That was our process failure. A positive marketing outcome did not remove the need for a clear agreement.

We changed our working rules after this project. Tasks need to be recorded in writing. Calls are followed by written summaries. Scope and financial agreements are handled through email and Asana, with WhatsApp as a backup text channel.

We stopped relying on Telegram for key approvals because correspondence could be deleted unilaterally. The reason was practical: we needed a stable place to return to the agreed wording.

This rule concerns instructions and approvals. It does not prevent an expert from dictating material that will later be edited into an article. A voice recording can be useful source material; it should not be the only record of a commercial commitment.

Why the disagreement belongs in this case

It would be easy to end this story with the table of enquiries. That would leave out a lesson we actually paid for in working time and friction.

We introduced clear attribution for incoming calls while leaving our own agreements open to different interpretations. The project showed us both the value of measurement and the cost of an unclear brief.

Our revised process asks for the same clarity on both sides: where an enquiry came from, and what work the client and agency agreed to undertake.

What another business owner can take from this

  1. Find out which contact route callers use. A long-established business can mistake existing recommendations for the result of a new campaign.
  2. Keep access to your own information. You should be able to inspect the website and business profiles you are paying to develop.
  3. Read a service page as a customer. Look for the service, relevant conditions and an obvious way to contact the business.
  4. Judge each source by the enquiries it brings. A directory, Maps profile and website can perform different jobs.
  5. Write down the scope before work begins. The next useful marketing step should not be held up by a dispute over the previous conversation.

The first useful change in this project was a separate phone number. It gave the owner a concrete way to test an assumption that had been driving spending.

Questions and answers

Does this mean local service businesses do not need websites?

No. We built new service pages as part of the solution. This case concerns an expensive website that was failing to bring enquiries and a change in how the company presented its services.

How did you distinguish Maps enquiries from website enquiries?

We used separate phone numbers for the different sources. That made the contact route visible without assigning all incoming calls to one channel.

Did ChatGPT bring the company new customers?

We did not isolate that source in the remembered results. Articles were part of the visibility work, but the case does not establish a separate volume of AI-generated enquiries.

Are the project costs a current offer?

No. They are figures recalled from this particular project. They describe the experience, not a current tariff or a promised budget for another business.

Get a consultation

All cases