Two garage brands and a courtesy Prius: a useful service change we failed to price properly
This case is told from the founder’s memory; figures are as he recalls them, not from a report. Details changed.

Who this case is for
Independent garages with several repair specialties on one site.
- Before: an unclear offer, inconsistent demand and skilled staff considering leaving.
- Our work: two distinct businesses, a courtesy car and a better waiting experience.
- Our mistake: delivering two sets of work within the budget agreed for one garage.
All cases · Construction company · Barbershop
What the client came to us with
The owner of an outlying garage wanted social media promotion. His wife’s salon had benefited from Instagram, and he hoped the same route would work for his business.
Google Maps had received little attention. Skilled mechanics did not have a reliable flow of work and were considering leaving.
The business occupied two neighbouring buildings on one site. Bodywork and paint repairs sat alongside engine and suspension work, but the public offer presented everything as one all-purpose garage.
We saw an opportunity to make the specialties clearer. We did not adequately account for how much extra agency work that decision would create.
What our review revealed
A prospective customer had little help understanding what each part of the garage did particularly well. We proposed presenting the existing specialties separately.
The visit itself also deserved attention. A customer leaving a car for more than a day had a transport problem. Someone having a quick repair still needed somewhere to wait.
Those were practical parts of the service that could be improved and then described. They did not depend on inventing a more impressive story about the garage.
What we changed
We created two distinct business presentations
Bodywork and painting became one business identity; engines and suspension became the other. We prepared two websites, two brand books and two Google Maps profiles.
The physical separation mattered. The work took place in two real workshops in different buildings, not two names applied to an unchanged listing.
The buildings received the designations “Building 1” and “Building 2.” Number plates were installed on site, with different signs and separate phone numbers. The businesses went through Google video verification.
These details explain what happened here. They are not an instruction to duplicate a profile or a promise that changing names will double search visibility. Building numbers alone do not establish a universal guarantee about a platform’s future decisions.
We introduced a courtesy car
For repairs lasting more than a day, customers were given a Toyota Prius to use free of charge. That addressed their need to travel while their own car was unavailable.
I remember this service generating substantial word of mouth. People had a concrete benefit to describe to friends.
The source does not give the loan paperwork, insurance arrangements or detailed restrictions. Those are not invented in this account.
We changed the waiting experience
For shorter jobs, the garage provided a coffee area and a place to take a photograph against the business logo.
The receptionist talked with visitors and invited them to describe their real experience, including through a review with a photograph. Customer images appeared on Maps and in directories.
Feedback remained the customer’s choice. The coffee and courtesy car were service features, not payment for a positive review.
We offered a reason for a first visit
Monthly promotions included free computer diagnostics for engines or suspension diagnostics.
Customers could see the clean workshop and become familiar with the business before discussing repairs. The founder’s account does not provide a count of subsequent repair orders from those visits.
What happened
The garage retained its best mechanics. As I recall, the two specialist profiles became highly visible in local searches for their respective services.
The courtesy car encouraged recommendations. The waiting area and receptionist’s conversations helped real customer experiences become visible in photographs and reviews.
There is no exact enquiry increase, revenue figure or occupancy measure to add. Nor do we have a measured recommendation result from ChatGPT or Gemini. More substantial information about the garage is not the same thing as a counted outcome from a named assistant.
The business separation and service improvements happened together. This case does not support a promise to occupy an entire local search market with two listings.
Our mistakes and what we changed
We agreed a price for promoting one garage.
Then our own strategy expanded the assignment to two distinct brands. We did not reprice the work before delivering it.
The agency produced two websites, two brand books and two Maps profiles within the old budget. The on-site identification and verification work also concerned two businesses.
The client benefited from the idea, but we absorbed a scope change that should have been discussed commercially. A good proposal can still be poorly managed by the agency that makes it.
After this project, we formalised a rule: when an audit leads to additional brands, locations or legal entities, the changed scope goes into a supplementary agreement. We revise the budget before the additional work starts.
An internal decision to “make two” is not enough. The client and agency need the same understanding of what the work now includes.
What another business owner can use
- Check whether customers can understand each repair specialty.
- Base separate presentations on how the business actually operates.
- Consider the customer’s needs during both long and short repairs.
- Show the real workshop and genuine visitor experiences.
- Reagree scope and price when one project becomes two businesses.
The courtesy car was relevant to this garage’s service. Another business needs to decide which practical problem it can solve within its own operation.
Questions and answers
How were two locations set up on one site?
The workshops occupied separate buildings. They received building designations, physical number plates, different signs and separate phones, followed by Google video verification. That describes this case without guaranteeing approval of every similar arrangement.
What role did the Prius play?
It gave customers transport when repairs lasted more than a day. The founder recalls people recommending the service to others.
Does every garage need a photo area?
Here it formed part of a waiting room with coffee and contact with the receptionist. A logo background on its own does not guarantee reviews or enquiries.
Was the second website a mistake?
The mistake was our pricing. We changed the assignment without changing the agreement before doing the additional work.